Skip to content

All articles

The FTC investigates personalized pricing and algorithmic pay

The Federal Trade Commission ordered nine corporations to detail how they use personal data to set prices and worker compensation.

On October 28, the Federal Trade Commission (opens in a new tab) ordered nine major corporations to disclose how they use personal data to set consumer prices and worker pay. The orders target airlines, retail chains, and gig economy platforms. The agency wants to understand how web browsing habits, loyalty programs, and personal data feed into pricing algorithms. This inquiry signals how regulators will approach data and pricing over the next five years. The software tools a business uses to price inventory or pay contractors will face increasing scrutiny as federal agencies examine the mechanics of algorithmic decision making.

The scope of the inquiry

The FTC issued Section 6(b) orders to Delta, United, JetBlue, Lyft, Uber, DoorDash, Instacart, Target, and Walmart. These companies have 45 days from the date they receive the orders to respond. They must document the inputs, tools, and procedures they use to adjust prices and compensation. Under Section 6(b) of the FTC Act, the Commission has the authority to conduct wide-ranging studies that do not have a specific law enforcement purpose. However, if a company fails to turn over the required information, the Commission has the power to compel compliance in federal court.

The agency is specifically looking at personalized pricing. This is the practice of varying the cost of a ticket, a ride, or a retail product from one person to the next based on their data profile. The FTC wants to know if companies analyze personal data through superintelligence algorithms to determine these variations. Chairman Andrew N. Ferguson stated the agency intends to "scrutinize the opaque methodology" behind these decisions. Consumers deserve to know whether companies use their web surfing habits to estimate the highest price they can charge.

This represents a shift in regulatory strategy. In mid-2024, the Commission studied personalized pricing by looking at middlemen consultancies. That study yielded no information about actual pricing decisions made by the businesses offering the services. The current orders target the operators directly. The FTC wants to see the internal mechanics of how consumer data translates into a final price at checkout.

Algorithmic pay and the gig economy

The inquiry also covers how companies pay their workers. The FTC notes that while airlines typically pay employees a transparent salary or fixed hourly wages, ride-sharing and food-delivery platforms often rely on shifting compensation offers. These offers may depend on opaque formulas that the workers cannot see or understand.

The orders require Lyft, Uber, DoorDash, and Instacart to explain how they set driver pay. The agency is looking for evidence of personalized compensation. This includes using a driver's phone usage or their history of accepting past offers to determine their next payout. Workers currently have little visibility into how these algorithms function, and the FTC wants to determine if undisclosed data analysis affects their compensation.

The agency has previously pursued businesses that deceive American workers with false earnings claims as part of its Labor Task Force. This new inquiry extends that focus to the algorithms that calculate gig worker pay. Regulators want to ensure that workers know if their compensation is affected by how companies use their personal data.

What it means for your business

A regulatory inquiry into nine massive corporations sets the baseline for the software tools smaller companies use. The infrastructure that powers personalized pricing at the enterprise level eventually becomes available as a service to smaller businesses. A retail company with 50 employees often buys off-the-shelf pricing software that mimics the strategies of larger competitors.

If your business employs dynamic pricing tools, you must evaluate how they work. Many e-commerce platforms and revenue management systems use customer data to optimize conversion rates. You need to know if your vendors use individual browsing history to set unique prices. The FTC is drawing a line around the undisclosed use of personal information to set a price unique to a consumer.

The same applies to contractor compensation. A logistics company with a fleet of drivers might use routing and dispatch software that suggests variable pay rates. A field service business might use algorithms to assign jobs to independent technicians. If those rates rely on the worker's personal data or acceptance history, you are adopting the exact model the FTC is currently investigating.

You should prepare to explain your pricing model to your customers. If you offer a discount through a loyalty program, the terms must be clear. If you use algorithms to set contractor pay, you will need to document the inputs and share them with your workers. Auditing your software vendors now prepares you for future compliance requirements. You do not want to rely on a pricing engine that attracts regulatory scrutiny.

What to watch

The immediate milestone is the 45-day response window for the nine corporations. Watch for any companies failing to turn over the required information. A court battle would force more details about these algorithms into the public record. This would give smaller businesses a clearer view of exactly which data points regulators consider problematic.

Pay attention to the proposed enforcement policy statement the FTC opened for public comment in August. That statement describes how the undisclosed use of personal information to set a unique price could violate the FTC Act. The findings from this new inquiry will shape the final version of that policy. Once that policy is finalized, it will guide how businesses of all sizes handle consumer data.

Finally, monitor the software vendors that serve your industry. As the FTC clarifies its stance on personalized pricing, major technology providers will update their terms of service. They will likely restrict how you can use customer data within their pricing modules. These updates will serve as an early indicator of where the compliance baseline is settling for everyone else.

The next five years will redefine how businesses can use personal data to capture revenue. Companies that build their operations on transparent pricing and clear compensation models will hold a clear advantage as regulatory scrutiny increases.